Rob Kirkman compares Rob Liefeld to Kirby? Please.
0 Comments Published by Avi Green on Sunday, October 29, 2006 at 10:52 AM.
Robert Kirkman, who's made a name for himself writing various Marvel books, recently compared Rob Liefeld to Jack Kirby, of all people in Wizard, the tabloid magazine on the comics world (Hat tip: Bobb)
Honestly, I think that Kirkman's gone a wee bit too far into silliness. Liefeld is one of the most overrated writers I know of from the 80s, and Cable sure wasn't anything to crow over. He was taken off of the 2 of 4 Heroes Reborn titles after less than a year in 1997, and what was a big mistake then was soon fixed when it became Heroes Return. As an artist, Liefeld's work ranges from okay to really awful, such as the recent job he did on Teen Titans, in Gail Simone's two-part story last year. Just take a look at the covers for the issues, #27-28. The necks are so weirdly penciled in there, look like they're filled with fat. GAH! Hawk and Dove deserve better than that. And once, when he drew a picture of Captain America in the late 90s, he made Steve Rogers look like a balloon! Another problem with his artwork is that the facial expressions are stagnant. Even his work at Image, where he was one of the first contributors to work for them, was worthless.
And yet, he strangely manages to make the comeback that various other writers and artists don't (Roger Stern is one writer I'd like to see make a comeback, but they don't even seem to hire him now). It's almost as if the editors are trying to insult the readers' intellect deliberately, and for all I know, they probably are. It's a feeling I got when Marvel assigned Humberto Ramos to draw Spectacular Spider-Man a few years ago too.
But whether DC and Marvel's willingness to keep on hiring him is deliberate, they certainly won't be tempting me anytime soon, that's for sure.
Honestly, I think that Kirkman's gone a wee bit too far into silliness. Liefeld is one of the most overrated writers I know of from the 80s, and Cable sure wasn't anything to crow over. He was taken off of the 2 of 4 Heroes Reborn titles after less than a year in 1997, and what was a big mistake then was soon fixed when it became Heroes Return. As an artist, Liefeld's work ranges from okay to really awful, such as the recent job he did on Teen Titans, in Gail Simone's two-part story last year. Just take a look at the covers for the issues, #27-28. The necks are so weirdly penciled in there, look like they're filled with fat. GAH! Hawk and Dove deserve better than that. And once, when he drew a picture of Captain America in the late 90s, he made Steve Rogers look like a balloon! Another problem with his artwork is that the facial expressions are stagnant. Even his work at Image, where he was one of the first contributors to work for them, was worthless.
And yet, he strangely manages to make the comeback that various other writers and artists don't (Roger Stern is one writer I'd like to see make a comeback, but they don't even seem to hire him now). It's almost as if the editors are trying to insult the readers' intellect deliberately, and for all I know, they probably are. It's a feeling I got when Marvel assigned Humberto Ramos to draw Spectacular Spider-Man a few years ago too.
But whether DC and Marvel's willingness to keep on hiring him is deliberate, they certainly won't be tempting me anytime soon, that's for sure.
Labels: dc comics, dreadful artists, indie publishers, marvel comics
0 Responses to “Rob Kirkman compares Rob Liefeld to Kirby? Please.”
Post a Comment