Did Marvel rip off designs for recent Iron Man armors from a Canadian publisher?
According to CTV News, a publisher in Montreal, Quebec that's worked to some extent with Image is suing Marvel for allegedly thieving designs from their illustrations to serve Iron Man, Ant-Man and Avengers illustrations:
A Montreal-based comic book company is suing Marvel Entertainment and Disney for allegedly ripping off its designs multiple times in its Iron Man, Ant-man and Avengers series.From what's told here, it sounds like C.B. Cebulski might've been involved, based on their Radix work:
Horizon Comics and its founders Ben and Raymond Lai allege that Marvel used their designs without consent or compensation and are suing for damages and an injunction "to put an end to this deliberate and persistent infringement, and to order the defendants to pay compensatory and punitive damages to the plaintiff, in addition to Horizon’s costs, including solicitor-client costs," the suit reads.
Horizon Comics was founded in Montreal in 1995.
The suit says Marvel's now editor-in-chief, Chester Bror Cebulski, approached the Lai brothers to work as artists for Marvel based on the popular series, but they declined the offer.And even the Massachussettes Institute of Tech. reportedly caused them distress, but the difference is that the New England-based research center offered a mea culpa:
The suit reads that MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) copied the illustration for a $50-million research grant to create the Institute for Solider Technology in 2002.Reportedly, the live action IM movies was where the uncredited copying took place:
MIT issued a public apology for using the images without consent. [...]
MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) copied one of the Radix characters in 2002 to get a $50 million grant, we decided not to sue because they publicly apologized and acknowledged their mistake. But with Marvel, it's repeat infringement. After years of litigation in the U.S. and substantial sums, they continue to copy our characters. It's causing us significant damage and impacting our ability to make a living as artists. It is clear that we cannot accept this repeated behavior. The only way to make things right was to file these proceedings."
Marvel's third Iron Man movie was released in 2013 and the brothers noticed similarities between the armoured costume worn by Robert Downey Jr. and their design.Obviously, this doesn't reflect well on Marvel's business practices, or moviemaking, and is only bound to further the negative perception anybody could've gotten of the publisher in the past 2 decades, ever since they threw away respect for their core audiences for the sake of soulless commercialism. If to take sides here, I will decidedly be supporting the Lai brothers and Horizon. Marvel most definitely shouldn't be slighting their dignity for the sake of their overrated modern publications.
The costume changed in each of the Iron Man films.
Iron Man's suit in the third installment is, the lawsuit reads, "strikingly similar to the suit worn by a Caliban, one of the characters portrayed in Horizon’s Works Radix 1."
Labels: Avengers, bad editors, indie publishers, Iron Man, marvel comics
I can see zero similarities in the designs, outside of the fact that Marvel INVENTED the form fitting style of metal armor seen in the images. I think it's pretty easy to prove the OPPOSITE of the lawsuit, that the Canadian artists ripped off Iron Man.
Posted by
Tonebone |
1:58 PM