Monday, November 16, 2026

How to win the culture war in the medium

Author Blaine Pardoe wrote on the American Thinker about how it got so bad in the USA comics medium and the movie adaptations in the past decade that anybody who cared and had the ability decided to create their own independent comics. He also says the following about James Gunn, recently dismissed from overseeing the DC film franchise:
Gunn claims he is a comic book fan, but he’s likely a fan of comics in the post 2016 era. For non-geeks, I’ll elaborate. Starting around 2016, the cancel culture crowd arrived in the comics industry. As always, it started small, with whiny protests, reading between the lines, looking for things to be offended at.

The movement was a minority but was loud. Comic book writers and artists who were conservative were booted from the industry they helped create. It even had a name, Comicsgate. The stories changed from being traditional heroes doing hero stuff to pushing political narratives. We saw Captain America give lectures about why illegal immigrants weren’t illegal; and he wasn’t alone. Woke ideology took the center stage. Characters were gender-swapped. Long-established characters were suddenly gay.
And to date, if we take Golden Age Green Lantern Alan Scott and Bobby Drake/Iceman as examples, DC and Marvel have vehemently refused to abandon those abrupt retcons. Exactly the problem, and of course, there's plenty more issues that need to be fixed, but will Skydance actually be willing to consider? If they don't, what's the use of an alleged conservative buying up Time Warner's assets?

And Pardoe may be right Gunn's not a true fan of comicdom, save for the situation that developed by the mid-2010s. Let's also remember his Superman movie contained stealth leftism.
The result? Sales have tanked. Diamond, the only major comic distributor at the time, went belly up. Comic stores closed. The woke did what they always do, ruined something that was cool and fun. As with everything, the woke as representatives of the modern audience, while loud, didn’t actually spend money.
On this, I would just add that Diamond was a very poor excuse for a distributor who mishandled some of their businesses, short-changed their clients, and above all, retail stores were surprisingly unprepared for managing business the same way most independent regular bookstores usually are. That is to say, if an indie-owned bookstore's managers know how to make arrangements with more than one distributor for delivery, how is it that any or all comics store managers didn't seem to know how to do the same? Okay, that's what it seemed like in hindsight, but if they really were solely relying on Diamond, that was monumentally stupid. It certainly was foolish that nobody years ago was willing to set up rival distribution services, allowing a whole culture of abuse to flourish through Diamond, whose business won't be missed.
Comics weren’t dead, though. The conservatives that were canceled or exiled rallied. Creators like Mike Baron, Ethan Van Sciver, and Chuck Dixon turned to crowd-funding to get their ideas and stories out. They all found success outside of the Marvel/DC universe after the cancel culture mob came at them.

Perhaps the most inspiring story is that of Eric July. Eric broke new ground, forming his own comic company, Rippaverse Publishing, complete with distribution. His comics are solid old-school comics with outstanding writers and stunning artists. Many of his books outsell DC at this point, showing there is a market beyond the woke. Of course, his success has come with a long line of online haters who refuse to see the irony of them trying to tear down a black entertainer/entrepreneur because he’s successful. Eric didn’t build a parallel economy in the world of comics, he reinvented how comics are funded and distributed. How very Elon Musk of him.
And he should be highly admired for that. That doesn't mean we should literally turn our backs on DC/Marvel, and allow the woke to continue abusing their products without opposition, of course. And if Marie Javins and Stephen Wacker have any more badness planned, or are still allowing it in their roles as editors, they should be removed from their positions, and Marvel should be sold to businesses who actually care. Assuming that's what Skydance's management considers themselves, that's why they have to do more than just take Gunn off the producers staff for the live action films. They have to look over the smaller assets they acquired and restructure DC comics' contributors, in example. They have to prove they can un-blacklist conservative writers like Baron, Dixon and Van Sciver, though if the latter were to return to the majors, he shouldn't take any assignments that would end up degrading the classic creations, which is what I feel van Sciver's leftist counterpart, Geoff Johns, did to Green Lantern, Flash and Avengers, in example. Johns' work should not be considered canon, period.

For now, anybody who cares and has the proper resources should continue building up alternate industries, which I believe is what Japan's got and has for a long time in manga. But at the same time, a case must still be made for why DC/Marvel must rescued from the woke forces holding them hostage. Come to think of it, a similar case must be made for why company wide crossovers have to stop, since all they've done in the long run was make it impossible for writers to tell a stand-alone story with genuine character drama. And why the monthly pamphlet format has to be retired.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

Flag Counter


track people
webpage logs
Flag Counter