Wednesday, November 18, 2026

How James Gunn wound up failing DC's film franchise as much as his predecessors

The Daily Wire looks at the career of James Gunn, who was decidedly overrated to begin with as a director, and how his supposed efforts to jump-start the cinematic DCU sputtered pretty quickly. Some examples are given from early in his career:
A young Gunn wrote two “Scooby-Doo” live-action movies at the dawn of his Hollywood career. Neither shed their kid-friendly trappings, but they snagged enough box office love to open some doors.

The 2006 horror-comedy “Slither” doubled as Gunn’s directorial debut. He nailed that genre hybrid thanks to a better-than-necessary cast and a cheeky sense of humor. Worm-like creatures invade a small town — a hamlet ill-prepared to fight back.

Nathan Fillion, Michael Rooker and Elizabeth Banks gave “Slither” some bite, and the film’s gross-out humor proved sophomoric and satisfying.

Gunn’s 2010 follow up featured a mid-“Office” Rainn Wilson as a sad sack who decides to take the law into his own hands. In “Super,” he crafts a clumsy superhero suit and crushes evil doers with an oversized wrench.

He learns super fame comes with its own complications, and when he attracts a wannabe sidekick (a pre-transitioned Ellen Page), our hero’s life takes a weird turn. Gunn’s attempt to sexualize that bond was more icky than awesome, a theme we’ll see later in his DC days.

Still, the film’s affection for the Everyman proved effective, even clever.
That he worked on a horror-themed movie decidedly says all we need to know what's wrong with his visions, and interesting Page was one of the cast members of his movies, because recently, not only has she gone out of her way to defend Frankenstein operations on children, she also took part in an anti-Israel demonstration in New York City. Someday, some might consider Gunn's resume more an embarrassment than a modern day classic, and in the end, why should his Scooby-Doo movies be thought of that way when they're little more than perpetual attempts by Hollywood to exploit even cartoons if that's what it takes to make bank?
That third movie got delayed when Disney briefly benched Gunn for old, problematic jokes. His sense of humor runs dark on a good day, and the woke mob nearly crushed his film career before cooler heads prevailed.

DC saw Marvel’s “Guardians” success and wanted him to bring it to their camp. So, Gunn attempted to revive a potential franchise and delivered 2021’s “The Suicide Squad” for Warner — a soft sequel to the 2016 “Suicide Squad” critic dud.
Oh for heaven's sake. The woke mob was hardly the one going after Gunn like they did Roseanne Barr, and the jokes he wrote were repulsive. Sometimes even words can hurt, and badly. What Gunn wrote was offensive to victims of sexual abuse, and the writer's not making mention that? Sigh. Not clearly mentioned is that the Suicide Squad sequel did make less than its predecessor, and if there's been no more sequels since, that does tell something.
His first major salvo as head of all things DC? “Superman,” a candy-colored reboot that often made the Man of Steel a side character in his own film. Super cameos flooded the screen. Superman bickered with Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan) and got beat up time and again.

Gunn picked a solid Clark Kent with David Corenswet, but time won’t be kind to Gunn’s messy reboot. The 1978 “Superman” with Christopher Reeve still flies high nearly 50 years later.
So does Superman II from 1980, and it's a pity the 3rd, 4th and Supergirl film from 1984 wound up wasting so much potential, as did the recent Supergirl film from this year, which is mentioned in the article.
On the small screen, Gunn took greater liberties on his HBO Max series “Peacemaker.” The second and likely last season, which debuted last year, featured a full-scale orgy in its first new episode. That’s a far cry from DC Comics norms.
I do know a special imprint of DC called Black Label may have featured implied nudity for Batman, but if the writer's implying DC never crossed the line before, he should look at what began turning up incrementally in the 1990s, and got worse post-2000. Identity Crisis was one of the worst examples, and Geoff Johns' writings at the time were another. Sexual situations, however, are a most interesting question in an era where they may have all but censored romance. I do know there were at least a few times in past decades where DC refused to put a serious emphasis on sex any more than Marvel may have, and the 1988-89 New Guardians series, spun off from Green Lantern, was apparently one of those. Yet their "moral" hypocrisy reared its ugly head when nasty crossovers like Bloodlines came about, followed by more awful examples the following decade, and again, Identity Crisis certainly crossed the line in how it trivialized sexual violence.
What went wrong? Gunn may be creatively spent, for one. Some creators lose their artistic vitality over time. It happens to the best Hollywood storytellers. Gunn was never an elite writer/director, but he carved out a respectable career.

Other wounds were self-inflicted. He took over a family-friendly brand and sexualized it via ”Peacemaker’s” second season. Gunn opted for less familiar characters, like “Clayface” and “Supergirl,” over beloved figures in the DC universe (Wonder Woman and Aquaman, for example).

He also unleashed the woke hounds on HBO Max’s “Lanterns,”
as if it were 2020, not 2026. The show drew solid ratings but quickly enraged Comic-Con nation by turning Hal Jordan (Kyle Chandler) into a bitter white man and playing up the saga’s sudden racial politics.
If Gunn and his colleagues are woke, what makes them think the woke mob actually pursued him several years back? Please, think again. Besides, DC may have once been family-friendly, if not kid-friendly, but what ruined everything was their sick turn to bloodletting in the past 30-plus years in the mainline universe.

I also have to disagree with putting Supergirl in the "less familiar" boat, and as revolting as it is to elevate a horror-thriller like what Clayface is, it's not that a character's "unknown" that's the problem. It's the lack of merit and talent that is. Marvel's Blade (originally seen in Tomb of Dracula in the 1970s) wasn't exactly a household name (and still isn't), yet the 1998 movie set the ball rolling on live action Marvel films to come post-2000. It's ridiculous to say non-familiarity is what does in a project instead of sloppy writing, acting and directing. And it's also insulting to say Supergirl's never been beloved, because she has had her share of fandom, and again, it's a disgrace Gunn and company perpetuated the destruction of Kara Zor-El's potential, much like DC still is now.

What Gunn seems to be known for over the past quarter century are "junk food" films, with the most laughable examples being Saturday morning cartoon movies, which won't amount to classics in the decades to come. But, his poor approach to filmmaking of recent certainly isn't helping, and if the sequel to his Superman movie thuds, I really couldn't care less. In the end, he's no improvement over Zack Snyder, that's for sure.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

Flag Counter


track people
webpage logs
Flag Counter